Do you think it's worth moving from Joe Thomas to this? This card looks good but only being 280 is kinda concerning. Might just get Ogden and the LT secondary.
Knowing the interactions in the trenches are ratings-based (also working with the base ratings); In the run game, only Suh has the block shedding needed to have an advantage (92 ovr):
Suh v. Thomas
92 BSH > 90 RBK
95 STR > 88 STR
Suh is heavier by 1 pound
Suh v. Munoz
92 BSH = 92 RBK, however...
95 STR > 91 STR, and...
Suh is heavier by 33+ pounds.
However, Suh is likely in the interior, so given that, there's really no other potential EDGE defender (on the right side) that can consistently beat Munoz in the run game. Thomas can still be consistently beaten by Deacon, Chubb, Howie, new LT, and Donald.
In the passing game, Munoz' PBP matches the highest PWM in the game right now, and only MUT Heroes Ingram can beat him consistently w/ a 94 FNM. You likely won't see anyone on the edge heavy enough or strong enough for those to matter. Thomas will get beaten by any top tier Power Rushers, and Ingram will dominate him too. Of course, abilities matter a ton anyway.
Long story short, based on what we know, only MUT Heroes Ingram can dominate both 1-on-1, based on his 94 FNM, and especially w/ abilities; otherwise, Munoz will hold up against everyone else, especially w/ abilities, unless you're up against Suh.
Weight hardly factors into anything. Not sure where that myth started. There’s a breakdown of the code and it debunks the whole “weight is a priority for linemen thing”
Which kind of proves the point that it hardly affects anything aha. 17% of the overall success rate formula. Being at 280 is 80% of the full 17% which winds up losing 3% compared to a max fat boy.
Aka the difference is negligible and nearly irrelevant. Important stuff for salary cap when every point matters and you’re running with silvers sure, but beyond that it’s useless.
Weight might not mean much now but once everyone has 99s, weight will be a factor in deciding who gets push or not. A 280 lb player with 99s everywhere is equal to a 330 lb player with 97s
that is true 280 is about 14% of the 17.5 but the problem lies only in the fact of bigger d ends like Reggie White or Aaron Donald or the other 280+ or even 270+ edge rushers because he also loses the strength and ratings to some also but that doesnt matter right now with how bad edge defenders are at defending the run might when madden drops the significant run patch they've talked about
The goat
Do you think it's worth moving from Joe Thomas to this? This card looks good but only being 280 is kinda concerning. Might just get Ogden and the LT secondary.
Knowing the interactions in the trenches are ratings-based (also working with the base ratings); In the run game, only Suh has the block shedding needed to have an advantage (92 ovr):
Suh v. Thomas 92 BSH > 90 RBK 95 STR > 88 STR Suh is heavier by 1 pound
Suh v. Munoz 92 BSH = 92 RBK, however... 95 STR > 91 STR, and... Suh is heavier by 33+ pounds.
However, Suh is likely in the interior, so given that, there's really no other potential EDGE defender (on the right side) that can consistently beat Munoz in the run game. Thomas can still be consistently beaten by Deacon, Chubb, Howie, new LT, and Donald.
In the passing game, Munoz' PBP matches the highest PWM in the game right now, and only MUT Heroes Ingram can beat him consistently w/ a 94 FNM. You likely won't see anyone on the edge heavy enough or strong enough for those to matter. Thomas will get beaten by any top tier Power Rushers, and Ingram will dominate him too. Of course, abilities matter a ton anyway.
Long story short, based on what we know, only MUT Heroes Ingram can dominate both 1-on-1, based on his 94 FNM, and especially w/ abilities; otherwise, Munoz will hold up against everyone else, especially w/ abilities, unless you're up against Suh.
So do I use deacon Ingram and bosa and unexfactor LT?
I’ve noticed x factored lineman have an advantage over linebackers when pass rushing
Thank you very much for this breakdown! Used my NAT Centennial to pick up Munoz last night.
No problem, I'm actually debating doing the same thing.
Nice breakdown.
Weight hardly factors into anything. Not sure where that myth started. There’s a breakdown of the code and it debunks the whole “weight is a priority for linemen thing”
mut leaks put out the run blocking formula https://twitter.com/MUT_Leaks20/status/1156002794869911552
Which kind of proves the point that it hardly affects anything aha. 17% of the overall success rate formula. Being at 280 is 80% of the full 17% which winds up losing 3% compared to a max fat boy.
Aka the difference is negligible and nearly irrelevant. Important stuff for salary cap when every point matters and you’re running with silvers sure, but beyond that it’s useless.
Weight might not mean much now but once everyone has 99s, weight will be a factor in deciding who gets push or not. A 280 lb player with 99s everywhere is equal to a 330 lb player with 97s
that is true 280 is about 14% of the 17.5 but the problem lies only in the fact of bigger d ends like Reggie White or Aaron Donald or the other 280+ or even 270+ edge rushers because he also loses the strength and ratings to some also but that doesnt matter right now with how bad edge defenders are at defending the run might when madden drops the significant run patch they've talked about
if only he got bucs chem :(
him or Trent Williams? (weight issue)