Muthead

Back to Help me see why Thielen > Barkley (Overdrive)

Single thread,
tb17

Ok, it's pretty obvious looking at the top 100 that way more people are having success with Thielen over Barkley. I am just about to finish my first season outside the top 500 because I tried to use Thielen for a whole season and I just don't get it. I get the 8x Receptions about 90-95% of the time, but my floor is just so much lower with Thielen that I'm losing more games when the doomswitch decides I lose. 

Has anyone used both and can tell me definitively why they prefer Thielen over Barkley? The pressures end up amounting to the same, and yea it's great to use different kind of plays but I haven't noticed my scores getting much higher, so maybe it's the play calling?