Muthead

Back to Level 20 & Torrey holt

Single thread,
cb2

No you're not doing something wrong. Just keep levelling up and he will become better and better. You get an Upgrade Token every 3 or 5 levels. Here you can see when you get Tokens through level 1-50: https://www.reddit.com/user/AndyHutchins/comments/cht86u/madden_ultimate_team_20_level_rewards_unlocks/