probably switch gameplans during your first drive by checking out your frequent plays
It's h2h so less likely and the whole sequence of events happened way too fast for it to be a live counter imo...and there have been a lot of "non countered" plays which look exactly like criticals.
This all went down in a matter of about 20 seconds...I mashed play again because I was salty about the safety...
http://imgur.com/gallery/AQTvUKP