Muthead
+0

Favorite MUT year?

I think most would agree this has maybe been the worst MUT ever. With that said which year has been your favorite? It's funny because if I rank them they get worse every year.

  1. Madden 25
  2. Madden 15
  3. Madden 16
  4. Madden 17
  5. Madden 18I only started playing Ultimate Team beginning with Madden 25, been playing Madden since 1994. Maybe why 25 is still my favorite but honestly 15 was pretty good too. I could make an argument for 15 being better as it was more polished. I just remembered the pack odds being fire in 25.
blakestrick

I think most would agree this has maybe been the worst MUT ever. With that said which year has been your favorite? It's funny because if I rank them they get worse every year.

  1. Madden 25
  2. Madden 15
  3. Madden 16
  4. Madden 17
  5. Madden 18I only started playing Ultimate Team beginning with Madden 25, been playing Madden since 1994. Maybe why 25 is still my favorite but honestly 15 was pretty good too. I could make an argument for 15 being better as it was more polished. I just remembered the pack odds being fire in 25.
Xtreme_Walrus

Mut 10 and Mut 25 for me.

aka_DirtySwish

It's just heartbreaking how many of you didn't play anything pre MUT 25. Mut 10, 11, & 12 were absolutely nothing but fond memories.

Everything since then has been a blatant cash grab, starting w/ MUT 13.

edjwen1

For me 16 was by far the best.  I like 18, but I will likely sell my team and move on when it is all said and done.  I still have and play with my 16 team.  16 the content was a lot better, more ways to make coins, more exciting packs, it was just better in every way.  I miss that one for sure.

blakestrick

I think the community as whole was better back then. You still had your scammers to look out for but for the most part everyone was civil. Not nearly as much hate and "good game" was common after most every game. Alot of opponents willing to help out, give tips, and talk about the game. Ahh the old times...

Mariotabeast

Quote from Pierce313131 >> 16. Stayed back a year on the ps3 while most moved to ps4. The little ps3 community was awsome.

This I had the same with mut16 the ps3 community made it even greater, just a small group of guys helping eachother out. We didn't need a clan or anything the ps3 community was their own "clan"

MUT 12 for me was my favorite there was just something about that game I enjoyed even though it didn't have solos and there were price caps to how much you could sell players for the collections and players and promos/ideas were just so fun in that game. Played since MUT 10 and that one is the one that sticks out for me.

stovy4x4ing

17 the one with the block buster promo was epic. Cant remember the year.

blakestrick

Quote from freeze28 >> 25= GOAT

Preach! Glad I'm not the only one who feels this way. I still have a god squad that was mostly transferred from PS3 to PS4, it's too bad there's no one to play on PS4.

freeze28

25= GOAT

blakestrick

Quote from Pierce313131 >> 16. Stayed back a year on the ps3 while most moved to ps4. The little ps3 community was awsome.

I played on PS3 and PS4 that year. I remember the market just kinda dried up on PS3 halfway through the year. Though that was really the last great year for the last generation of consoles. Because MUT17 was a joke if you played on PS3/360 they pretty much stopped supporting it halfway through the year. Guess that's why 17 was the last one on last gen.

Pierce313131
  1. Stayed back a year on the ps3 while most moved to ps4. The little ps3 community was awsome.
Latinprince22

16 for me

SkyloxTDK

17-25-15-16-18 I loved 17, until like you all said, content just kinda took a big nose dive

Anime

I definitely felt like Madden 17 was on pace to be one of the best MUTs but after the gauntlets stopped, content started to slow down. The content up until January was great.