I got Mack solely for the ability to set the edge and eat up any stretch to one side. If pass rush is more important always go with speed on the edge.
For you I would go Kearse just for the TT boost. I do like Mack though as i like to play him inside at DE and DT sometimes. I think strength and powermove are more important there. So i guess it depends on how you use him on defense.
I play both. Kearse at rush dt and mack at rush de.
I would probably take Kearse short term and mack longterm
Edited by nccane9
kearse is going to be much faster, but if you think long term mack will get more frequent upgrades
If you are on a eagles theme - I'd recommend Kearse
This because of Theme. I had Mack and Freak up until I sold Kearse. I picked Mack for theme.
I'm having a hard time deciding. Javon would be 90 speed on my eagles TT. However, Mack has good traits and more PMV. I usually stay in nickel sets. I only use 4-3 for the run.