Muthead
+0

NFL QB Matchup Dan Marino v Peyton Manning

Open Discussion 

Bracket  https://challonge.com/mca0azii

Spyder2YBanana

2 different QBs really.  Marino has the best combination of arm and accuracy the games ever seen and Manning was the greatest at reading the defense and making the adjustments to find the window.

bowlerivory

Overall I'd have to go with Manning

PatNation

I’m going with Marino

PatNation

Quote from dolphaholic >> he broke marino's records. and for those of you that think quarterbacks win and not teams, manning has 2 rings to marino's 0. so like, you can't make any argument here.

 He also broke them 20 years later when the rules were completely different

unleashedfury47

Manning,  As much as I loved Dan Marino as a player, Manning's work ethic, his football intelligence and pre snap abilities was pure genius. 

Marino had all the physical qualities to make a solid QB good arm strength accuracy and the ability to throw the ball a million times a game. However he was probably the slowest QB the NFL has ever seen.

bruinrogue

Marino. If he had even half a competent defense or run game, he would've won a SB. He was putting up points and yards when the NFL was a run-supportive league. In this current league, you sneeze on a WR or QB, you get a flag.

Grumble

Marino could pass for 6k yards in a season if they had the rules now back then. Marino

DarkPassenger

Marino is the greatest pure passer in history. Manning is a choke king. If I needed one of these guys to win a championship there is no way in hell I'm taking Manning. Give me Marino all day.

Kirito

Quote from dolphaholic >> manning. i'm a dolphins fan, and even i'm admitting it. cmon yall

 but ur only admitting it because you have Peyton :troll:

dolphaholic

he broke marino's records. and for those of you that think quarterbacks win and not teams, manning has 2 rings to marino's 0. so like, you can't make any argument here.

dolphaholic

manning. i'm a dolphins fan, and even i'm admitting it. cmon yall

HarshP722

Close one but I'm going with Manning

stairwaytose7en

Dan was great, but I have never seen anyone better presnap than Manning.

dadejazz

Pure passing marino is better,  accuracy n strength.