SilentWolf

Welp, this didn't age well for me.

I may not be in the huddle, but by doing something called watching the game, I can tell that Chinn has been everywhere. Young doesn't even lead his own team in sacks. He hasn't been as disruptive as your making him out to be. Chinn is one of two players on that Panthers defense making a difference. Hes carrying that defense as much as he can. He has a redzone interception, numerous touchdown saving tackles, 9 games with 8 tackles or more, a strip sack that nearly led to a defensive touchdown, and back to back fumble return touchdowns, one of which he stripped the ball himself. Chinn has been a beast and a playmaker. Not that Young hasn't either, but Chinn has played at a whole different level than Young.

Because PFF isnt in the huddle. They don't know what players assignments are, they don't know what the play actually is. They just tag numbers on players who they think are playing better than others. You also cant grade two different players who play different positions on the same 100 point scale. If we go by whose had more of an impact to their team, which is what the award should be, Chinn should be DROY.

Whose grading these rookies? Kinda hard to prove a point without a source. And if you say PFF, just know that they are in no way credible.

Why should we look at one game when the award is based off of the whole season? Chinn has been one of the few bright spots in a bad Carolina defense. Chinn has the team lead in tackles with 110, 2 FF, 2 FR, and 2 TD, and hell, he has 4 QB hits as well compared to Youngs 9. Chinn has been a player you need to gameplan for while young has been average. But because hes the #2 overall pick, everyone thinks Young should win.

Muthead overprioritizes weight and strength for the 3-4 dt position. While yes there are definitely thiccer dt's out there, MJG's stats completely out weigh those players, making him just better. Better way to look at it would be would he be better in a 3-4 for a 4-3 (and thats all just personal preference, he works fine in 3-4 easily)

2 TD vs a top 3 Run D aint easy to do either

If they were trying to take panthers fans, they wouldn't have given CMC the measly +1 OVR upgrade.

Yea I wish that EA kept those cards. Players that had a good game, but not incredible games. If they had kept the two weekly TOTW heroes and smaller 77-85 ovr cards, but add the historic performance heroes as well like they did, this promo could have been a big W. But now its too early to tell, just gotta wait and see.

Yea the addition of the inactive players is really nice. They mentioned during the stream that they took out the lower overall players because they weren't too usable for top end teams and were almost never used. So they gave Power Up players who had standout weeks the OVR bump and took the lower overall cards out of TOTW, and will add a Team Affinity set that will kinda replace these players, and it will be based around players making a name for themselves. That part is expected to come out some time between series 2 and 3.